Food + Dining Shopping + Style Arts + Entertainment Mpls.St.Paul Magazine Parties and Party Pics Travel + Visitors Homes Health Family Weddings
Adam Platt

« Father’s Day: Barack Obama’s Gift of Candor | Main | On Dissent »

June 27, 2008, 10:40 AM

Bad Form: Wolves Shiv Sid

By Adam Platt

One of the more common refrains of sports fans, especially those who call into Sunday morning radio shows, is that the local sports media is cynical, negative, don’t ever see the glass as half full. Pat Reusse, even to my jaded ears, wears on me with his utter disdain for so many sports figures, historical and current.

Then something reminds me why he’s right.

If you had been online last night at approximately midnight, you would have realized that long after the NBA draft ended, the Timberwolves pulled off a huge trade, sending its highly regarded number three pick, OJ Mayo, to Memphis for the less-than-sure-thing Kevin Love. A passel of other players changed hands as well.

I’m not going to evaluate the merits of the trade, look here for that, and here’s some trenchant background.

After I read the news on the Star Tribune’s website, I scanned the rest of the sports articles, and my jaw dropped. Under Sid Hartman’s name were these words, “Wolves wanted Mayo all along”. Clearly the sports legend had written his column before the midnight trade. Under Jim Souhan’s byline: “Wolves made the right choice [Mayo]”.

Hartman’s column, now revised with the headline “Wolves liked Mayo and Love”, was particularly embarrassing. “There was never any doubt,” he wrote. “Wolves assistant general manager Fred Hoiberg verified Thursday night that Mayo was their choice all along. Hoiberg said the Wolves never came close to making a trade. The truth of the matter is they think so much of Mayo that they wanted him on the team.”

“Our people thought that Mayo had far more upside than Love,” Wolves owner Glen Taylor told Sid.

Later in the column, team boss Kevin McHale told Sid that the Wolves “couldn’t be happier” guard Greg Buckner is under contract, as he’s a role model and teacher. “He is a world-class kid.” Buckner was traded to Memphis along with Mayo.

I am not here to bury Sid or Souhan for that matter. And I’m sure the Wolves, at Friday’s press conference, will tell the media the trade came up out of the blue, the team didn’t expect it, and it only traded Mayo because it was able to acquire other key players and unload stiffs. And that may be partly true, but it’s also partly b.s.

The team has deservedly taken a lot of heat over the years for bad basketball and poor management decision-making. Pat Reusse laid it on the line earlier this week. It is certainly entitled to hate the local press and mislead them on draft night (though when you speak to the press, you are speaking to your fans, I’d remind them).

But Sid is a different story. He may not always support you, but he is the only sportswriter in town that always gives management the benefit of the doubt—the opportunity to spin disingenuous drivel in the name of authoritative source material—and a guy who never takes a cheap shot.

The Wolves knew it was dangling Mayo, knew something might be brewing, and knew it valued Love almost as much as Mayo. They all lied. Someone owed it to at least Sid to whisper, “Hey, more may happen tonight, don’t run those quotes until you check with me” or something to that effect. It happens all the time.

Instead, Taylor, Hoiberg, and McHale demeaned themselves and the entire Wolves organization by their disingenuousness and burned the one local scribe who always roots for their success.

Classless.

Comments

I know someone who is not going to have their comp courtside seats renewed.


BS. Classless? How about the Strib's sports team being clueless?

The Wolves were in the middle of a deal they have been trying to close for weeks and Sid runs a quote that no one else has or, I believe, has since verified. Meanwhile, the Memphis Commercial Appeal waits until the next morning and runs a time line that shows exactly how the whole thing went down.

Anyone who has watched 1 or 2 NBA drafts know the trades break late; sometimes after the beginning of free agency. Yet here's good ol Sid and Souhan not only writing columns that preemptively burn the Love bridge (Souhan suggested he was paid in cheesburgers; Sid has a quote that appears no where else and I don't think has been seconded by Taylor) while the MCA waited a few hours and got the story right.

Perhaps had Sid been something more than a court stenographer and had taken the context of how the NBA draft works, the T-Wolves pretty thinly disguised desire for Love, and a long, long history of late-breaking draft trades, they wouldn't have rushed a bunch of poorly checked and thinly sourced BS to their on-line edition. The Wolves were doing their jobs. Not so much with Sid and Souhan.

Wow, I apologize for all the errors. I cut and pasted it from Word and there are several things missing. Oh well, I think the point is clear.

Whisper? To Sid? He's deaf as a stump!

I've only lived up here twenty years now, so I only know a small fraction of the Sid Hartman story, but the end of his career I've been exposed to is that of a home team hack who publishes whatever he's told to print.

When it comes to Wolves coverage, I've come to respect Britt Robson, Steve Aschburner, and a few others, but not Sid or Reusse, two very tired, burned out sports reporters whose opinions I value not at all other than when I'm researching the latest arguments for making taxpayers pay for new stadiums for billionaire sports team owners.

Post a comment

We do not moderate comments. However, mspmag.com will remove comments if they contain profanity, offensive content, and/or overt sales pitches.


Type the characters you see in the picture above.

« Previous | Main | Next »


mspmag.com | Mpls.St.Paul Magazine © 2008 MSP Communications, Inc. All rights reserved